Factors that Impact Insurance Rates

Why is my insurance rate so high?

This is a question so many have been (furiously) questioning and understandably so. It’s true, insurance rates are astronomically high right now and we all are feeling the impact. Even insurance experts with 50 years in the industry are saying they have never seen such a volatile market like the one we are living through. There are a number of reasons why the insurance market we are currently in is so unique which may provide a better understanding for the increased insurance rates.

#1. Market Conditions

Although the inflation crisis has shown some signs of leveling out, it takes time for the rest of the world to catch up. Additionally, experts say that although the rates should decrease in the coming years, it’s highly unlikely that insurance rates will ever go back to the prices from 3 to 5 years ago. Inflation is not just a concern for consumers, but for insurance carriers as well. Insurance carriers also have reinsurance coverage through a reinsurance carrier (yes, your insurance carrier has insurance!). So not only is it more expensive for insurance carriers to payout for claims but their insurance premiums have increased as well. If inflation was the only variable, insurance rates would lag a bit behind but when you factor in all the other issues going on simultaneously, it creates a perfect storm.



#2. Increase in Claims

Even if you’ve never had a claim in 50 years, the sad truth is that other peoples’ claims have an impact on your insurance rate. Why? Insurance is a shared risk.


Carriers take a collaborative approach to reduce the financial risks with unforeseen events, disasters or accidents. Not only have claims been increasing significantly and rapidly, the severity of these claims have dramatically increased as well. Insurance carriers don’t have the same amount of reinsurance funds or returns as they used to. Since the industry is a for-profit business, returns are necessary for survival. With returns dropping significantly over the past 2 years, many insurance carriers have either resorted to sending out non-renewals or stopped writing new business…or both. The burden of finding a new insurance company may be frustrating, especially when that rate is $1500 more expensive than your previous policy, but ultimately these insurance carriers are acting in your best interest. If forecasting shows they can’t handle the exposure, the only option is to reduce clientele, stop writing new business or increase rates.


#3. Severe Weather

The increase in the number of weather events, the severity of these weather events and the increase in abnormal events for certain locations has made forecasting the frequency and value of claims nearly impossible. Insurance carriers base their entire business around prediction models. Weather has become more unpredictable than in the past. When too many events take place in a short amount of time, many insurance carriers simply cannot keep up. They either become insolvent (go out of business), reduce clientele sometimes based on risk exposure or they increase insurance rates.

#4. Cost of Living

It’s no secret that life is just more expensive now. Based on our grocery receipts and restaurant tabs, I think we can all agree on this! Insurance is not immune to this increase. One of the reason claims are more expensive is due to the increase cost of labor and supplies. Hiring contractors, lawyers, auto body repairmen, and paying for the supplies to repair the property, equipment or car is more costly than it’s ever been. Insurance carriers are paying more to settle claims. In turn, the replacement value of your home insurance must be increased and effects your insurance rate. Automobile technology is advancing at a rapid pace and many of these technologies include devices to safeguard drivers from accidents which is great. But these high-tech and hybrid vehicles are also more expensive to repair or replace.


It’s a Domino Effect

The significant increase. in insurance rates is due to a combination of: market conditions + an increase in claims + an increase in weather events + the cost of living. All of these factors create a domino effect and an undesirable hard market. For more insurance education, tips & trends, sign up for McShea Insurance Agency’s newsletter by clicking HERE to stay informed.


If you would like a free quote for your home, auto, umbrella, boat or business insurance, please email us & one of our expert agents will be able to assist!

Large, weathered, multi-story shingle-clad house with multiple balconies and a covered porch in a grassy dune setting.
By McShea Insurance January 8, 2026
Thinking about buying a home on Cape Cod or the Islands in 2026? Don't miss these essential insurance tips! From roof age to flood zones, learn what to watch out for before making an offer. Download our free checklist to ensure you're covered.
Snow-covered rooftops with chimneys against a light sky.
By McShea Insurance Agency December 5, 2025
Learn when roof collapse from heavy snow is covered by home or commercial insurance on Cape Cod, Nantucket, and Martha’s Vineyard, plus tips to prevent damage.
Frozen Pipes
By McShea Insurance Agency November 10, 2025
Protect your Cape & Islands home from frozen pipes this winter with simple prevention tips, smart leak tools, a free checklist PDF, and a no-cost policy review.
What’s Your Business Really Worth? (And Why It Matters for Your Insurance Policy)
By by McShea Insurance | What’s Your Business Really Worth? (And Why It Matters for Your Insurance Policy) October 14, 2025
Your business is worth more than its assets! Discover why an undervalued business income insurance policy leaves you financially exposed—and how to align your coverage with your true value (including reputation & future growth) to survive a shutdown. Take our quiz now!
Cape Cod, MA
By McShea Insurance September 5, 2025
Coastal homeowners in MA face rising premiums but is your coverage keeping up? Learn what to check in your home insurance policy and how to protect your property on Cape Cod, Nantucket, and Martha’s Vineyard.
Construction crew in helmets reviewing blueprints on site, highlighting teamwork and safety planning
By McShea Insurance August 26, 2025
Learn how ignoring safety warnings can put your business at risk. From restaurants to construction, see how the right insurance keeps you protected.
Homeowner reviewing documents with an insurance agent:
August 5, 2025
Why did your home insurance get canceled after inspection? Learn common reasons for failure—and how to pass with confidence on Cape Cod and beyond.
What Flood Insurance Actually Covers  (And What It Doesn’t)
By McShea Insurance Agency July 14, 2025
Learn what flood insurance really covers (and doesn’t) for Cape Cod, Nantucket, and Martha’s Vineyard homeowners. Don’t risk costly gaps—get expert guidance from McShea Insurance.
Coastal home on Cape Cod protected by Home Insurance
June 24, 2025
Learn 6 coastal home insurance red flags Cape Cod, Nantucket, and Martha’s Vineyard homeowners should watch for. Get expert help from McShea Insurance.
An aerial view of a hurricane in the ocean
May 28, 2025
by McShea Insurance | Experts in Coastal & High-Risk Property Insurance